Once dominated by Polish-Americans, Hamtramck’s city government takes a turn

By Charles Sercombe
You can sum up Tuesday’s election results in one word: Historic.
For the first time ever in Hamtramck – and possibly in the nation – a Muslim majority is now in control of city government.
And for the second time in the city’s history a Yemeni-American will hold a seat on council.
Saad Almasmari, a Yemeni-American businessman who owns an ice cream supply company, came out as the top vote-getter in his first attempt to win a seat on council. He follows fellow Yemeni-American Abdul Algazali who served on council until his death earlier this year.
The council now has three Bangladesh-Americans, two of whom, Anam Miah and Abu Musa, won re-election on Tuesday.
The Bangladesh and Yemeni communities have been growing in recent years. For decades Hamtramck has been a predominately Polish town, but those of Polish descent now find themselves in the minority, or nearly so.
According to U.S. Census figures Hamtramck’s Muslim community now represents 50 to 55 percent of the community, which includes those from Bangladesh, Yemen and Bosnia.
This historic turn of events was not lost on Ibrahim Algahim, a political activist in the Yemeni community.
In a recording posted on Kawsar Dewan’s Facebook page, Algahim spoke at a victory celebration held at Kabob House on Conant for Almasmari, Miah and Musa after Tuesday’s election.
What he said at that meeting might disturb some in the community.
“Today, we showed the Polish and everybody else that we are united,” Algahim said.

Before speaking about the election Algahim introduced the winning candidates from that night’s election, including Councilmember Mohammed Hassan, who he called “the future mayor of Hamtramck.”
A speaker who followed Algahim, whose name was not discernible in the recording, talked of receiving a “message” from an Imam in Yemen for the community to deliver a victory.
The speaker said voters did just that by electing Almasmari, a Yemeni-American.
Later in the meeting Dr. Khalid Almasmari stressed that the council must work for the entire community.
“It’s time to show the people what Muslims can do in Hamtramck. We’re going to work for all of Hamtramck,” he said.

You can see the recording here: https://www.facebook.com/kawsardewan/posts/10206717716434514?pnref=story
The three candidates not only won on Tuesday, they left the three trailing candidates in the dust. About 300 votes separated the third-place winner, Anam Miah, from the fourth place winner, Susan Dunn. The difference from the top vote-getter to Dunn is 480 votes.
So, does this election represent a tipping point for future elections?
There are a few theories floating around town. City Clerk August Gitschlag said there were only a handful of new voters registered since the primary election in August.
But what he did notice was a number of registered voters who had not been active before who came out for this election.
And on the flip side of that equation, he said, there were many voters who simply refused to vote because none of the candidates appealed to them.
“Do you know how easy it is to not vote?” he said.
One thing you can bet on in future elections, those formerly inactive voters who voted for the first time last Tuesday will be coming back to vote.
Gitschlag also pointed out that two years ago the mayor and Councilmember Andrea Karpinski received the vote numbers that the top three vote-getters received in Tuesday’s election.
What that boils down to is that the three top vote-getters, Almasmari, Miah and Musa, who ran as a slate, got their base out to vote.
They also actively campaigned in the neighborhoods going door-to-door. It’s a formula that has been proven effective time after time.
The losing three candidates did little or none of that.
Councilmember Musa went the extra mile on Saturday and Monday and brought in over 50 voters into city hall to vote via absentee ballot. A Review reporter witnessed Musa standing by the voting stations in city hall, telling fellow Bangladeshi voters to vote for him.
Although campaign workers must stay at least 100 feet away from the entrance of polling locations, Gitschlag said it’s legal for candidates to stand in city hall and tell those voting by absentee ballots how to vote — as long as they are not in the actual voting station.
Musa’s encouragement to voters to vote via AV ballot paid off. He received the highest number of votes, 398, using this method. Councilmember Robert Zwolak, the only incumbent to lose, received the second highest number of AV votes, 276.
In total there were about 700 AV ballots cast.
While being an incumbent is generally a guaranteed way to win re-election, Zwolak said a number of things worked against him.
He said it first started with debate over who should fill a vacant seat on council following the death of Titus Walters. There were many in the Bangladeshi and Yemeni community who insisted it should have been Rashad Almasmari.
The city administration’s interpretation of the city charter said the next person in line from the last general election was a different candidate, Ian Perrotta. The issue was settled in Wayne County Circuit Court where a judge ruled in favor of the city’s interpretation.
That issue seemed to have galvanized the Muslim community.
Zwolak said the next issue that energized the Muslim community was a formal complaint filed with the city by candidate Susan Dunn over the volume of the call to prayer from a mosque near her house.
And then, a mysterious flyer appeared, or so it seemed, that smeared Dunn, Zwolak and Cathie Gordon. The flyers alleged the three were behind an effort to “Get the Muslim out” of the city.
Dunn made the flyer public, although there was only one known person who claimed to have received the flyer, who just happened to be candidate Saad Almasmari, a neighbor of Dunn. Local media outlets went with the story despite there being little proof the flyer had even been distributed.
Zwolak criticized Dunn for bringing attention to the flyer, saying it was “stupid” to rile up the public.
As for Gordon, a former councilmember, this might be the end of her political career. Two years ago she decided to drop out in mid-term on council in order to run for mayor.
She lost out in that bid, coming in last place, and she again finished last in her attempt to come back on the council.
But as the saying goes, never say never.
The reaction to this election, which produced a Muslim majority city council, ran the gamut on Facebook. On Mayor Karen Majewski’s Facebook page there were those questioning when Sharia law would be instituted and bars closed down to those who said the anti-Muslim comments were racist.
Local television news stations also reported on the election and the new Muslim majority. The comments on those websites were venomous in their hatred of Muslims and Islam.
Those welcoming Tuesday’s election results included School Boardmember Evan Major.
“In the face of nasty Islamaphobia on the national stage, I believe Hamtramck is now the first U.S. city with a Muslim majority governing body,” Major said on his Facebook page. “That’s pretty cool. And I’m glad to celebrate this symbolic victory with my friends and neighbors tonight. Our town is a special place.”
Also commenting on Facebook was Naz Huda, a Bangladesh-American and supporter of Councilmember Miah. In his link to a WDIV Channel 4 report on the election, he said:
“Cheer to all my haters! Be Patient … So much more is coming.”


This article was updated on Nov. 5.

13 Responses to Once dominated by Polish-Americans, Hamtramck’s city government takes a turn

  1. Resident

    November 5, 2015 at 10:07 am

    1. Turn out was low – < 25%.
    2. Susan Dunn single handedly united brown voters.
    3. If it weren't for Susan Dunn, Cathie Gordon would have gotten more votes.

  2. Joe McCordy

    November 5, 2015 at 10:56 am

    Now Jesus can become known as the only Son of God. The muslims now elected will have to allow freedom of speech. They can not stop the truth of Christiantiy and Jesus Christ as the way to heaven. It is time the muslims open their hearts and ears to God’s word.

    The truth needs to told how the fellow who wrote the Koran, Mohamed, was a plagerist that stole the writings from the new testetment. And remember the Koran was written 650 years after God gave his son Jesus as our saviour.

    Finally the evil of Islam can be exposed without free of retibution.

    Just say no to Sharia Law!

  3. o j

    November 6, 2015 at 11:24 am

    sharia law has nothing to do with it… last i heard this is the United States of America….

  4. Moh

    November 6, 2015 at 11:28 am

    The whole nation or (the whole word is watching) … they have to be really careful and thing twice before saying or doing anything.
    and remember you work not just for one side
    you work for Jews right
    you work for Christan right
    you work for Muslim right
    you work for Atheist right
    if the person is white, black, gay , …etc
    every single citizen has to be treated equally under your leadership
    Do otherwise and be sure it will be recorded in the history books.

  5. Resident

    November 6, 2015 at 1:18 pm

    Moh- the brown voter didn’t vote based on religion. They voted for the people with whom they could relate to. If the two council men of Bangladesh origin (Anam & MUsa) were Hindu or Buddist, they would still have gotten the same votes and would have gotten elected/re-elected.

  6. RM

    November 9, 2015 at 1:58 am

    Ugh. Why do people always have to bring religion or race into this or care what demographic your majority is. Worry about whether stuff gets done or not. Remember, we have separation of church and state.

  7. Paula Selwaaski

    November 12, 2015 at 12:12 pm

    This won’t end well. Muslims can’t be trusted.

  8. Lynn Philip Hodgson

    November 23, 2015 at 2:46 pm

    Having been a Councillor for 7 years, I can tell you that it is NOT good for a city when a majority ‘slate’ is elected. It means that the opposition has been become powerless and that the ‘slates’ plans for the city will become bi-laws as the ‘slate’ will control each and every vote; not good…..

  9. Mohammed

    November 25, 2015 at 8:07 am

    here are some true Bigots on this comment section.

    Paula- you are truly a person that does not have any Muslim friends, because that comment shows how close minded person you are, and how you will never explore outside your boundary because of the hate you have in you.

    Joe- You are another closed minded person, who said some untrue fact. If you were a true American you would respect the First Amendment. Freedom of religion

    I think everyone who made bigot comments, should understand if you were true American you would respect the Constitution.

  10. Roadman

    November 29, 2015 at 7:37 pm

    What a historic election!!

    Covered in the Wall Street Journal, Christian Science Monitor and other periodicals all the way to London.

    Peace and unity to the City of Hamtramck!

  11. Buckwheat

    December 5, 2015 at 10:23 am

    Ah, Hamtramck… that wonderful city where the median household income has dropped from $28,699 to $25,813 (or, if you wish, 12.3 percent) from 2009 to 2014. Yes, Hamtramck, the same city where the poverty rate climbed from 38.4 in 2009 to 48.5 in 2014. Hooray, the Mooslims have taken over… all is bright for Hamtramck’s future.

  12. JMA

    December 29, 2015 at 9:39 am

    noooooo this is bad juju. just watch and see!

  13. Resident off Hamtramck

    January 6, 2016 at 11:14 am

    Let’s just blame each other that’s the easy part ! I like everyone in Hamtramck i dont care what race religion ill i care is for Hamtramck too go forward not backwards clean around your houses plant trees change your roofs put siding on your house clean your allley behind your garage if you see something wrong report it there is so much we could do for a city but it’s easier too blame religion or city council or Jesus or Allah or Sharia law just like KIDS go outside and clean or help your orderly neighbor clean his lawn or something i dont care what people say about my Hamtramck fellow people or news or whatever

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *